A while back I replaced my trustworthy Thinkpad T61 with a Dell Precision M4500. The only problem I had with the Thinkpad was with Nvidia not liking external monitors. (It would restart X when an external monitor was connected, and then the external would be the default monitor. Any attempt to e.g., clone both screens or even to change the default back to the LCD panel would just crash X again.) Since that’s pretty much a deal-breaker for a teacher, I decided to “upgrade” to a Dell Precision. I wanted something in the same “mobile workstation” class, with a good (non-chiclet) keyboard and touchpad. But the Precision has been much more trouble than the Thinkpad ever was (although external monitors do work with reasonable reliability). I’ve been gradually working through the issues as I have time.
Nvidia Sometimes makes Compiz/X Hang or Crash
Sometimes, after logging in, either Compiz will fail to start (leaving me with
un-managed windows) or will fail to render anything (giving a black screen) or
X will hang completely. The former two cases can be “solved” by killing X
(or, equivalently, restarting
mdm), but the latter requires a magic-SysRq
restart. After reading the usual round of irrelevant forum posts and old bug
reports, I’ve tracked down a combination of changes that seem to mostly solve
Make sure Grub doesn’t switch to the graphical console (or tell the kernel to do the same):
/etc/defaults/grub and then run
update-grub.) Note that even with
this change the kernel still switches to fbcon halfway through the boot
Blacklist the Nouveau kernel module: add a line
blacklist nouveau to
Remove the Nouveau X driver (make sure you have the official Nvidia drivers, obviously):
apt-get remove xserver-xorg-video-nouveau
Also note that if you have to restart X, it may leave a zombie Compiz running
in the background, taking 100% CPU (which, on an 4-core machine, is not even
top and then doing
kill -9 pid will fix that; just
make sure you kill the right process.
A related issue seems to be that sometimes the Mate Panel is displayed on screen but not actually mapped, so you can’t click on it. Killing the panel fixes this, but it’s annoying.
Touchpad is Crazy Sensitive
The touchpad was so sensitive I could move the mouse cursor without touching the pad, just by hovering my finger over it. Also, the whole “disable the mouse while typing” thing doesn’t work, which, when combined with the above sensitivity, means that the mouse cursor likes to jump to random locations in my document while I’m typing.
evtest reports some crazy low pressure values: sometimes it will even report
movement events with zero pressure. Although the Synaptics driver supports
setting min/max thresholds for pressure that will register as clicks, I haven’t
yet figured out if it supports just an overall “ignore all events below this
The following settings (in
.xinitrc) is supposed to fix the sensitivity:
But it just has the effect of making the touchpad less sensitive to intentional presses. Accidental touches seem to occur just as often. There doesn’t seem to be a single setting that will set a minimum threshold for pressure to register at all (i.e., as either move or press events).
Note that some people recommend changing the “FingerPress” setting, but that has been removed from newer versions of the driver.
For me, checking the box in the mouse settings that says “Disable while typing”
has no effect. I had to add
syndaemon -i 0.5s -d to my startup script manually
to disable the touchpad while I’m typing.
Dell’s UEFI Implementation is Beyond Broken
Going into the BIOS setup at all completely breaks the normal UEFI boot order.
In order to boot back into Linux afterward I have to hit F12 to bring up the
boot menu, and manually select the
ubuntu EFI option. It doesn’t matter that
ubuntu is set as the first, or only, boot entry; if I let the boot go through
without my intervention it will hang at a black screen (pre-Grub). The “solution”
efibootmgr to change the boot order so that the
entry is not first in the list, but comes after some inactive entry;
in my case, the first entry is that of legacy boot for the very same HD hosting
Mint. (The “Modular Bay HD” has Windows 7; it’s replacing the DVDRW drive that
would normally be in the expansion bay.) Note that this
change cannot be made through BIOS; although the BIOS utility will show what
are apparently the same settings, they won’t work. Here’s what the
efibootmgr -v looks like (with my system currently booting direct
Timeout: 0 seconds
Boot0000 Diskette Drive BIOS(1,0,00)
Boot0001 Internal HDD BIOS(2,0,00)P0: Crucial_CT256MX100SSD1 .
Boot0002 USB Storage Device BIOS(5,0,00)USB Storage Device.
Boot0003 CD/DVD/CD-RW Drive BIOS(3,0,00)
Boot0004 Onboard NIC BIOS(6,0,00)
Boot0005* ubuntu HD(1,800,100000,4c57ed8c-a81a-4074-9270-85c4a244fd60)File(\EFI\ubuntu\shimx64.efi)
Boot0006* Modular Bay HDD BIOS(2,0,00)SATA: ST9250410AS .
Boot0008 Internal HDD BIOS(2,0,00)SATA: Crucial_CT256MX100SSD1 .
Boot0009* USB Storage Device BIOS(5,0,00)
BootFFFA* Internal Shell Vendor(5990c250-676b-4ff7-8a0d-529319d0b254,)
BootFFFB* Diagnostic Boot Vendor(5990c250-676b-4ff7-8a0d-529319d0b254,)
BootFFFC* Temporary Boot Menu Vendor(5990c250-676b-4ff7-8a0d-529319d0b254,)
BootFFFD* Graphic Setup Vendor(5990c250-676b-4ff7-8a0d-529319d0b254,)
BootFFFE* Text Setup Vendor(5990c250-676b-4ff7-8a0d-529319d0b254,)
Note that you will have to manually restore this boot order if you do anything
that might change or reset it, such as upgrading grub. Merely changing the
grub config (
update-grub) is fine, however.
I should note that Dell’s implementation is just flaky in general: It seems to largely ignore the boot order specified in EFI, and even though it reports supporting the EFI shell, it will refuse to boot into it. You also cannot use BootNext to tell it to launch (e.g.) BIOS setup on next restart. And it will restore some EFI settings on startup, overwriting any changes you’ve made: you cannot remove the boot entries for physical drives, and they will automatically be added to the BootOrder. (I’ve actually both deleted entries 0006 and 0008, and removed them from the boot order. They were restored and re-added after a restart. There used to be a 0007 entry; it’s missing this boot for some inexplicable reason.)
(Note that you can’t use
efibootmgr to modify the UEFI boot settings unless
the system was booted in EFI mode. This means that if you started the system
in legacy mode (e.g., to run a live CD) you cannot use it to fix your boot
settings. But many newer live CD/USB distributions can also be booted in EFI
mode; it’s just something to be aware of.)
Despite being objectively faster (both in terms of clock speed, and core count) and having more memory than my T61, the Precision is noticeably slower. This is with the same model SSD that I had in my T61. I haven’t managed to track this down.